Apprenticeships ‘are not offering social mobility’

The apprenticeship method is failing disadvantaged youthful people in England, warns the Social Mobility Fee.

The commission also suggests the Covid-19 pandemic will make factors even worse and will exacerbate youth unemployment.

In a report, it highlights a 36% decline in people from deprived backgrounds starting off apprenticeships, compared with 23% for other groups.

The Department for Training claimed it was “definitely fully commited to levelling up opportunity across the place”.

The Social Mobility Commission’s report was posted as the Training Decide on Committee took evidence about apprenticeships and competencies at a session on Wednesday morning.

Apprenticeship levy

The report, Apprenticeships and social mobility: Satisfying possible, says the introduction of an apprenticeship levy in 2017 has led to a “collapse in over-all apprenticeship commences that hit disadvantaged learners toughest”.

The apprenticeship levy usually takes .5% of the wage invoice from significant businesses that have an annual pay out monthly bill above £3m, with the intention of applying the money to make improvements to techniques and supply teaching.

The report finds that concerning 2015-16 and 2017-18, the quantity of apprenticeship starters from disadvantaged backgrounds fell by a lot more than a 3rd (36%), as opposed to 23% for other apprentices.

It also highlights:

• only13% of degree-level apprenticeships (the most high priced apprenticeship alternative) go to disadvantaged apprentices
• only 63% of disadvantaged males productively total apprenticeships, in comparison with 67% of the far more privileged
• on normal, apprentices from disadvantaged backgrounds gain fewer than all those from non-disadvantaged backgrounds.

The commission’s report also suggests that most of the added benefits of apprenticeships are heading to people from wealthier backgrounds.

But it stresses that apprenticeships are “one particular of the most successful suggests of boosting social mobility for workers from poorer backgrounds – if they can get into and by means of the technique”.

Direct report author, Alice Battiston from London Economics said: “There is a intense downside gap all over the entire apprenticeship coaching journey, and this has worsened more than time.

“Not only has the proportion of new starters from deprived backgrounds declined above time, but they have also benefited fewer than their far better-off peers from the shift to larger-amount programmes.”

Steven Cooper, joint deputy chair of the Social Mobility Fee, said: “The apprenticeship levy, introduced in 2017, has disproportionately funded greater-amount apprenticeships for learners from more advantaged communities, alternatively than individuals from deprived socio-financial backgrounds who would advantage far more.

“It is no for a longer period credible for the authorities to presume that apprenticeships immediately enhance social mobility and depart the program to its individual units,” he mentioned.

“Strategic action and route are required to focus on the process far better on disadvantaged communities and enhance the system’s benefit for cash.”

Coronavirus influence

Adhering to the coronavirus pandemic, there are considerations that disadvantaged apprentices are at further more threat from an financial drop, with quite a few used in challenging-strike sectors this kind of as hospitality and retail.

“The pandemic is most likely to have created the downside hole worse. There desires to be urgent thought of the impact of the apprenticeship levy on social mobility outcomes,” additional Ms Battiston.

Labour’s Shadow Schooling Secretary Rebecca Extended-Bailey mentioned apprenticeships would be one of the constructing blocks of economic restoration right after Covid-19.

“If the governing administration is severe about offering an ‘apprenticeship guarantee’ it will heed calls from the further education and learning sector for a put up-Covid skills funding package deal, deal with the boundaries to accomplishment and assistance companies to present the options and good fork out new apprentices need to succeed.”

“As this report reveals, a lot of disadvantaged apprentices experience important limitations to achievement by now, but with warnings from the FE sector that a lack of new destinations and massive figures of apprentice redundancies could be on the horizon, their long term may well search even bleaker with out urgent federal government motion.”

A DfE spokeswoman reported: “We are certainly committed to levelling up option throughout the place, and proceed to do all we can to make guaranteed no-a single is left at the rear of as a final result of coronavirus.

“Apprenticeships are an excellent way to get into a extensive array of fulfilling professions and they will keep on to engage in a very important part delivering the higher-high-quality competencies companies and our economic climate will require to get better.

“We are looking at how we can make guaranteed far more people today and corporations can get gain of apprenticeships in the foreseeable future, including supporting businesses, particularly tiny and medium sized businesses, to acquire on new apprentices this year.”

Adhere to Katherine on Twitter